{"blocks":[{"alt":"Reproduction of Key Text Messages","caption":"Reproduction of Key Text Messages","height":420,"html":"","media_id":"769","text":"","type":"image"},{"alt":"","caption":"","height":"740","html":"\n
\n

October 19, 2024

\n
iOS Messages
\n
Lucy Craig
i don\u2019t have a payment to take an uber
\n
Lucy Craig\u2019s roommate
Can I order you one?
\n
Lucy Craig
i\u2019m riding w [house mother] behe
\n
Lucy Craig\u2019s roommate
great!
\n
\n

October 20, 2024

\n
Snapchat
\n
Jonathan Nool
Free pussy in alum pu
\n
Fraternity member 1
This is crazy work
\n
Scott Norris
Free...
\n
Scott Kretzschmar
diego went 7 min ago and is not afk sooooo
\n
Matthew Ingalls
I fucking love chi phi
\n
Matthew Ingalls
\u2764\ufe0f\u2764\ufe0f
\n
Winston
CHI PHIII
\n
Scott Kretzschmar
the alumni shit is not a bit. first person pov not a bit.
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Like you can walk in and whip it out rn
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Blurry image of Lucy Craig
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Image
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Image
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Image
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Image
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Image
\n
Fraternity member 2
Shop still open\ud83e\udee3
\n
Fraternity member 2
?
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Yeah
\n
Matthew Ingalls
\ud83d\ude08
\n
Scott Norris
Yeah
\n
Fraternity member 3
No way!
\n
Scott Norris
LFG
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Jonathan laying rn
\n
Fraternity member 4
Nice
\n
Fraternity member 4
Nice guys
\n
Fraternity member 4
Is my room open?
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Lowkey he\u2019s cucking all of us
\n
Fraternity member 4
Nvm
\n
Scott Norris
Fraternity member 4\nIs my room open?\nFuck off mid
\n
Scott Norris
Kid
\n
Fraternity member 4
I want my license
\n
Fraternity member 3
Are you guys at least naked??
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Boys come whip it out
\n
Matthew Ingalls
\ud83d\udd25
\n
\n
iOS Messages
\n
Lucy Craig\u2019s roommate
You coming home tn?
\n
Lucy Craig
idk
\n
Lucy Craig
Herm
\n
\n

October 21, 2024

\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Diego Sarabia
\n
Diego Sarabia
Hey I just got your number and heard that I may have said some mean things when I walked in the room but I truly do not know what I said. I want to make amends with you because I\u2019m not a mean person I pride myself on being kind and am rlly sorry for that and what\u2019s going on. Is there anything I can do for you to bring peace to the matter I just talked with your friend but really want to know more about what I can do to apologize. I never meant to be in that situation or do anything to hurt your feelings
\n
Diego Sarabia
If you want to call later would be happy to apologize with words
\n
Diego Sarabia
Scotty also said he\u2019s sorry and should have never been in that room
\n
Lucy Craig
I really appreciate the text and i didn\u2019t think in your heart you were a mean guy or anything. i figured it was a defense thing cause like that was obv an insane night and i think everyone was really confused, drunk, high, and nervous. i really do still think highly of chi phi and im not a person to pretend i don\u2019t know people after any sexual affair no matter the magnitude. so i do look forward to seeing yall around. while we\u2019re all obviously denying what happened to anyone who asks, i hope that we can joke about all this (in private obv) later down the line
\n
Lucy Craig
also i do remember there were two scotty\u2019s?? unless i was getting fucked w but one of them sat beside me and told me to take a few minutes before i got up and i really appreciated his care for my wellbeing. sometimes it\u2019s easy to feel a little dehumanized in a heated sexual situation and i appreciated his pausing for me to collect myself. if u wouldn\u2019t mind telling him i said thank u that would be great <3
\n
Diego Sarabia
Yes, so sorry once again and I agree with it just being an insane night and appreciate your forgiveness - and right, with due time it can be something to laugh about privately. Yeah there were two Scotty\u2019s haha. I\u2019ll tell him that you are thankful he did that, that was really nice of him. Thanks again for understanding
\n
Lucy Craig
i think we all have a soul bond now cause very few people can say they\u2019ve had an experience like that. while it\u2019s good to keep it away from the public i don\u2019t think it\u2019s something to feel ashamed of in private. thank god there are two scotty\u2019s that was literally the trippiest part of the night
\n
Lucy Craig
\ud83e\ude77
\n
Diego Sarabia
Ya I get that and super happy I could clarify that. Def a confusing component lol
\n
\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Jonathan Newell
\n
Jonathan Newell
Hey [Lucy Craig] this is Jonathan [classmate] gave me ur number. I just wanted to apologize for how things went down the other night. My memory\u2019s kinda fuzzy abt a lot of it but me and Matt both feel like shit for being too fucked up to shut it down and kick people out before it got way out of hand. You\u2019re an amazing person and I genuinely hope ur not catching as much heat from this as we r. We\u2019ve been shutting down any stories we\u2019ve heard but again I\u2019m so so sorry.
\n
Lucy Craig
\ud83e\ude77
\n
Lucy Craig
aw jonathan i really appreciate this text. my memories super clouded too. i think we were all way to fucking drunk and high. i\u2019m getting a little heat (pi phi girls ([classmate] and [classmate]) can\u2019t get my name out of their mouth)) but that\u2019s to be expected. but at the end of the day non of the sexual stuff was illegal and honestly i really liked being w u and matt. so anything anyone has to say about the gamgbang is out of their jurisdiction. i don\u2019t think we should feel any shame for the part. our body our choice asf,,
\n
Lucy Craig
also yes while it may have been nice for like only 4 people to have been around, yall were both super out of it and they should have taken it on themselves to leave. at the end of the day you, matt, and i were in your bed and they didn\u2019t need to get up in that.
\n
Lucy Craig
but if you have any regrets or anything you want to talk about i am always here to talk about it cause that was a lot. i really do love u and matt and i promise i wont get quiet and weird w u like i did last time <4
\n
Lucy Craig
ps. i\u2019m not sure if u remember but i did ket off your dick at some point\u2753 and i honestly think that was one of the most insane/jaw dropping moments of the night
\n
Jonathan Newell
I\u2019m just glad ur ok, I was kinda upset w all the stories going around earlier but at the end of the day that\u2019s all they r
\n
Jonathan Newell
And I have no memory of that last part\ud83d\ude2d
\n
Lucy Craig
oh jesus not the stories i don\u2019t even think i wanna know. i know im socially a massive slut rn and i like can\u2019t bare to hear it cause im really not.
\n
Jonathan Newell
And I have no memory of that last part\ud83d\ude2d
\n
Lucy Craig
insane truly
\n
Lucy Craig
oh jesus not the stories i don't even think i wanna know. i know im socially a massive slut rn and i like can't bare to hear it cause im really not.
\n
Jonathan Newell
Funny enough I haven\u2019t heard ur name yet in any of them, someone thought [fraternity member 4] od\u2019d in the room tho
\n
Lucy Craig
i heard that one too but it was the night before??.. honestly it was such a good time for it to happen cause i heard everyone went feral that friday and saturday
\n
Jonathan Newell
Oh ya it was
\n
Jonathan Newell
But pretty good timing, just makes everything less believable
\n
Lucy Craig
it\u2019ll be funny in a couple months
\n
Jonathan Newell
So funny
\n
Lucy Craig
we should smoke again sometime but like leave out the extra 5 billion men and ketamine
\n
Jonathan Newell
Oh definitely
\n
Jonathan Newell
I\u2019m off hard drugs for good
\n
Lucy Craig
oh also i lost two earrings so if u find them that\u2019s my bad
\n
Lucy Craig
me too
\n
Lucy Craig
\ud83e\ude77
\n
Jonathan Newell
I\u2019ll look when I clean tmrw after class
\n
Lucy Craig
marked it on rice purity so i\u2019m good i\u2019ve got all the mom lore i need
\n
Jonathan Newell
\ud83d\ude02
\n
Lucy Craig
\u270c\ufe0f\ud83e\udee6
\n
\n

October 23, 2024

\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Matthew Ingalls
\n
Lucy Craig
bro everyone knows \u270c\ufe0f i\u2019m incredibly stressed out,, some random bitch [classmate] told some of my friends i don\u2019t even know who that is how tf she know me???
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Dude I have no fucking idea, this shit is incredibly frustrating and now I know how fast nonsense spreads at this school
\n
Matthew Ingalls
It\u2019s fan behavior from everyone talking about it
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Boring people who have nothing to do with their time. It\u2019ll blow over in a couple days I imagine, until then we just have to sit tight. How\u2019ve you been coping with the stress? You need anything?
\n
Lucy Craig
i will also say this is fucking RUINING my life temporarily
\n
Lucy Craig
my reputation is destroyed and i\u2019m utterly ashamed
\n
Lucy Craig
i\u2019m fucking pissed cause this many people shouldn\u2019t know and i feel like i know who some of the rats in the room were. if i ever find out i swear to god its in sight
\n
Lucy Craig
literally people are making it crazier every fucking day
\n
Lucy Craig
on top of it i have a uti and all i do is sleep and cry all day
\n
Matthew Ingalls
I\u2019m so sorry dude this sounds incredibly overwhelming and fucked up on all fronts. I\u2019ve been dealing with similar stuff on my end but obviously it doesn\u2019t compare to what you\u2019re going through. The most reassuring thing I can offer is that this WILL blow over and soon. Stupid bitches like to yap, and the fact they\u2019re doing it shows that they\u2019re jealous of you for any number of reasons. I understand the regret, but personally I don\u2019t think you have anything to be ashamed of. The only shameful thing is how this spread and how people won\u2019t shut up about it - which just reflects poorly on them tbh. As for the UTI - I\u2019m pretty ignorant about how that works but if there\u2019s anything (medicine, a call, etc) you need from me then let me know and I can make it happen. This sucks dude, but we\u2019ve both been through worse, right? I\u2019m sorry if this isn\u2019t what you\u2019re looking for but I\u2019m here for you anyway \ud83e\udef6\u2764\ufe0f
\n
Lucy Craig
\u203c\ufe0f
\n
Lucy Craig
you\u2019re right it\u2019ll get better and u think everyone\u2019s j jealous of us.. but also like everyone needs to grow up cause sexuality and sex and shit is changing and stuff like this is going to become more common,, i\u2019m also really open minded tho. i luv u king,, also tell anyone who gives u shit that i\u2019ll actually beat them up that don\u2019t want the smoke i promise
\n
\n

October 24, 2024

\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Jonathan Newell
\n
Lucy Craig
[classmate] said i should talk to u rn? what happened
\n
Jonathan Newell
Huh?
\n
Jonathan Newell
That\u2019s odd nothing happened
\n
Jonathan Newell
Ohh I was at pi phi last night I think that\u2019s it
\n
Jonathan Newell
I went like fully prepared to be interrogated and deny everything but they never even brought it up
\n
Jonathan Newell
I think it\u2019s mostly blown over by now
\n
\n

October 25, 2024

\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Matthew Ingalls
\n
Lucy Craig
jonathan def told people. i heard something today and i know he told people. he was a pi phi two nights ago too
\n
Matthew Ingalls
He didn\u2019t talk about it at pi phi for sure. They wouldn\u2019t bring that up in front of him when his story has been it\u2019s not true the whole time. I\u2019ll ask him - though it was definitely one of the upperclassmen in the room who told someone else and it spread
\n
Matthew Ingalls
That one isn\u2019t believable though
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Who told you this? If we can narrow down the girl we can narrow down suspects
\n
Matthew Ingalls
I know it wasn\u2019t Jonathan
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Trust me he would never
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Who told you this? If we can narrow down the girl we can narrow down suspects
\n
Lucy Craig
she wouldn\u2019t tell me who she heard it from cause it\u2019s one of her friends so i\u2019m j dropping it i give up im defeated
\n
Lucy Craig
\ud83e\ude77
\n
Matthew Ingalls
I\u2019m so sorry [Lucy Craig], ik this sucks a lot but I think (hopefully very soon) these idiots will move on and it\u2019ll be done with
\n
\n

October 26, 2024

\n
Greek Rank
\n
Greek Rank post
Are Chi Phi brothers Crips or Bloods because I hear they have been doing hell Gang Banging?
\n
\n
Greek Rank
\n
Greek Rank post
They do drugs and gang r*ped a sophomore. Report them
\n
\n

October 27, 2024

\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Sorority
\n
Classmate
Have u heard the rumor about ur little?
\n
Lucy Craig\u2019s sorority \u201cbig sister\u201d
yeah shut it down this is out of control
\n
Lucy Craig\u2019s sorority \u201cbig sister\u201d
actually disgusting
\n
Lucy Craig\u2019s sorority \u201cbig sister\u201d
it\u2019s disgusting that people think this is funny to talk about when it would be rape if it were to happen
\n
Lucy Craig\u2019s sorority \u201cbig sister\u201d
some pi phi girl started it
\n
Lucy Craig\u2019s sorority \u201cbig sister\u201d
she had a threesome but that\u2019s it
\n
Classmate
And the way that even if that did happen ppl blame [Lucy Craig] and not any of the guys
\n
Lucy Craig\u2019s sorority \u201cbig sister\u201d
per usual people love to blame women for being abuse victims or make them out to be sluts
\n
Lucy Craig\u2019s sorority \u201cbig sister\u201d
always blaming the victim not the rapist
\n
\n

October 30, 2024

\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Matthew Ingalls
\n
Matthew Ingalls
\ud83e\ude77
\n
Matthew Ingalls
[Fraternity president] wants it to be known that if ANYONE acts remotely disrespectful when you come tomorrow that you should come to either me or him and he\u2019ll fine their ass and kick them out of the party - they won\u2019t be able to sleep at the house at night. He also told me to tell you that chi phi is your house and you are welcome here at any point
\n
Matthew Ingalls
\ud83e\ude77
\n
Lucy Craig
thank u i really appreciate that <3
\n
Lucy Craig
i\u2019ll bring my cigs tomorrow\u203c\ufe0f
\n
Lucy Craig
i luv that man
\n
Matthew Ingalls
[Fraternity president] wants to call you real quick so expect a phone call
\n
Lucy Craig
i was uninvited
\n
Lucy Craig
but ofc it was \u201cfor me\u201d
\n
Lucy Craig
i knew this was going to happen. the woman will always get the short end of the stick.
\n
Lucy Craig
yall aren\u2019t my friends. yall are covering your asses.
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Wait are you sure
\n
Matthew Ingalls
[Fraternity president] told me you\u2019re still invited
\n
Matthew Ingalls
You are still invited
\n
Lucy Craig
he can go fuck himself
\n
Lucy Craig
i\u2019m done
\n
Lucy Craig
he is not a friend of mine
\n
\n

October 31, 2024

\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Matthew Ingalls
\n
Matthew Ingalls
How\u2019re you doing? [Fraternity president] told me you\u2019re still good to come and he was offering advice - where\u2019s your head at?
\n
Lucy Craig
no
\n
\n

November 3, 2024

\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Jonathan Newell
\n
Lucy Craig
let\u2019s be clear that 90% of what happened that night was not consensual. i was given more key than i can remember and i know that i told u i felt uncomfortable and i didn\u2019t know anyone in the room. all i remember after that was u giving me ket to do off your dick in front of everyone like a sex doll/worker.
\n
Jonathan Newell
And I don\u2019t remember any of this happening which is why Ive been feeling so terrible abt the whole situation. And I know that is no excuse and neither is how fucked up I was but i genuinely want u to know and hope u know that had I been less fucked up and even somewhat aware of the situation and how out of hand it got I would\u2019ve shut it down the second guys started walking in the room. Like [Lucy Craig] I am so so sorry for everything that happened that night and everything you\u2019ve been going through since. U r genuinely someone I respect so much and one of the strongest ppl I know and even though you\u2019re pissed with me for what happened which is completely warranted, I still want to be here for u as someone u can talk to or come to when u need anything. Again, I\u2019m so so sorry and there\u2019s no excuse for anything but I\u2019m begging u to please talk to me bc I wanna be here for u thru this
\n
\n

November 7, 2024

\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Matthew Ingalls
\n
Lucy Craig
call me
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Practice just ended give me 7-8 and I\u2019ll be home
\n
Matthew Ingalls
All okay?
\n
Lucy Craig
i mean no i\u2019ve been to ER this week
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Shit. I\u2019ll hurry home rn
\n
Lucy Craig
what is winston\u2019s number
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Okay leaving now give me a couple
\n
Lucy Craig
?
\n
Lucy Craig
one second on call w winston
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Call whenever, might be in the shower if I miss it
\n
\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Matthew Ingalls
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Can I call rq?
\n
Lucy Craig
i\u2019m w my mom
\n
Lucy Craig
what\u2019s up
\n
Matthew Ingalls
It\u2019s alright, never mind. It\u2019ll sort itself out hopefully
\n
Lucy Craig
what? just give jist
\n
Matthew Ingalls
My ex told me that I\u2019m being labeled as an assaulter in the public eye, I was going to ask if you may have said something along those lines to someone but I know you wouldn\u2019t
\n
Lucy Craig
i haven\u2019t said anything but i do know people are changing the narrative because like in any sexual scenario w one woman and many men the woman was probably victim
\n
Lucy Craig
i know there are rumors i was gang banged
\n
Lucy Craig
i\u2019ve never said anything against u but i have about jonathan
\n
Lucy Craig
i had a friend who was going to chi phi and i said don\u2019t
\n
Lucy Craig
but i\u2019ve never mentioned your name
\n
Matthew Ingalls
\ud83d\udc4d
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Okay, I appreciate that a lot, thank you \ud83d\ude4f
\n
\n

November 8, 2024

\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Fraternity group
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Fuck
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Should I call [Lucy Craig]?
\n
Fraternity president
no not yet
\n
Gillio Lopes
Jesus Christ
\n
Fraternity president
Wait a bit for me and Eboard to figure out what were doing cuz there are a couple other things going on
\n
Fraternity president
we also want to wait and see if she says anything
\n
Fraternity president
Cuz it might not necessarily be her who sent it
\n
Fraternity president
Just going off the title
\n
Fraternity president
ingalls when was the last time you spoke to [Lucy Craig]
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Yesterday
\n
Jonathan Newell
Wait what was the 25th
\n
Fraternity president
Now that you mention it, not sure.
\n
Fraternity president
Dates dont add up
\n
Fraternity president
Wait that was the night with [Lucy Craig]
\n
Fraternity president
what party did he have the 19th
\n
Matthew Ingalls
[Fraternity president], what\u2019s the plan of action? Should I call [Lucy Craig]? I don\u2019t think she would have reported this
\n
Fraternity president
Unless they mixed up the dates
\n
Fraternity president
Wait to call [Lucy Craig]
\n
Fraternity president
Ill tell you when to
\n
Fraternity president
I dont think she did either
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Copy
\n
Fraternity president
But we need to figure out what is actually happening first
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Are we gonna need to dissociate?
\n
Jonathan Newell
The 25th was risky business party
\n
Gillio Lopes
Newell and I were on bar that whole party
\n
Gillio Lopes
What could this be referring to
\n
\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Matthew Ingalls
\n
Matthew Ingalls
[Lucy Craig], you free to call soon?
\n
Matthew Ingalls
\u201cCornell armada\u201d when we call
\n
Matthew Ingalls
Sending so I remember
\n
Lucy Craig
what?
\n
Lucy Craig
i think i\u2019m done talking to you. i know you lied.
\n
Matthew Ingalls
What? Can you call?
\n
Lucy Craig
no. never again
\n
Matthew Ingalls
[Lucy Craig] what did I lie about?
\n
\n
Campus crime alert
\n
Crime Alert
From:\nCrime Alert\nSent:\nFri, Nov 8 at 6:22 P.M.\nTo:\nCrime Alert\nSubject:\nCrime ALERT: Sexual Assault \u2013 Edgemoor Lane, City of Ithaca\n\nOn November 8, 2024, the Cornell University Police Department received a report of a sexual assault.\n\nThe victim reported the incident occurred on October 25, 2024, or during the early morning hours on October 26, 2024, in the 100 block of Edgemoor Lane in the City of Ithaca. The victim reported being sexually assaulted by several males and coerced into consuming ketamine and other drugs. The fraternity where this incident occurred has been temporarily suspended, effective immediately.\n\nThe investigation is ongoing. Anyone with information regarding this crime is asked to contact the Cornell University Public Safety Communications Center at (607) 255-1111.\n\nCornell Police firmly believes that crime is never the fault of the victim. Cornell Police reminds the community to walk in groups and utilize the RAVE Guardian app when on or near campus.
\n
\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Scott Norris
\n
Classmate
You were in the room no?
\n
Classmate
What\u2019s the vibe in the house rn
\n
Scott Norris
I went in to check out what was actually going on
\n
Scott Norris
Seemed consensual and normal when I was in there
\n
Classmate
What\u2019s the vibe in the house rn
\n
Scott Norris
Have no idea
\n
Scott Norris
Prob shitty
\n
Scott Norris
Seemed consensual and normal when I was in there
\n
Scott Norris
I didn\u2019t see any sexual acts tho
\n
Scott Norris
So idk
\n
\n

November 11, 2024

\n
iOS Messages \u00b7 Gillio Lopes
\n
Matthew Ingalls
What\u2019s the name of your lawyer
\n
Gillio Lopes
Lemme see
\n
Gillio Lopes
?
\n
Gillio Lopes
Sorry
\n
Gillio Lopes
I meeting with him tmrw
\n
\n
","media_id":"","text":"","type":"html"}],"canonical":"https://lucycraig.blog/article/reproduction-of-key-text-messages","description":"Read the text exchanges reproduced here.","keywords":["reproduction","key","text","messages"],"markdown":"https://lucycraig.blog/article/reproduction-of-key-text-messages.md","published_at":"2026-11-08T17:35:04+00:00","section":"","subtitle":"We reproduced various messages and exchanges in the Lucy Train Hoe Craig case","summary":"Reproduction of Key Text Messages","title":"Reproduction of Key Text Messages","updated_at":"2026-11-08T17:47:57+00:00"}