{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"DigitalDocument","altText":"ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED ) (Motion #001) Partially Signed OTSC as to Pseudonym","alternateName":"NYSCEF-Document-000002.pdf","caption":"NYSCEF document #2 | Filed: 2026-09-16 | Filed by: COHEN, ETHAN J Filed:  Received: | Current docket status: Processed Confirmation Notice | Court: New York County Supreme Court","contentUrl":"https://lucycraig.blog/media/357/raw","datePublished":"2026-10-15T18:45:39+00:00","description":"NYSCEF document #2 | Filed: 2026-09-16 | Filed by: COHEN, ETHAN J Filed:  Received: | Current docket status: Processed Confirmation Notice | Court: New York County Supreme Court","encodingFormat":"application/pdf","identifier":"357","isAccessibleForFree":true,"machineReadable":{"json":"https://lucycraig.blog/media/357/index.json","markdown":"https://lucycraig.blog/media/357/index.md"},"name":"ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ( PROPOSED ) (Motion #001) Partially Signed OTSC as to Pseudonym","ocrStatus":"ready","ocrText":"--- Page 1 ---\nAt\nof the Supreme Court of\nthe State\nof NewYork County of NewYork,\nheld\nat the Courthouse located\nat 60 Centre\nStreet, NewYork, NY10007 on the\nday of\n20\n.\nP RE S E NT:\nHON.\nJustice\nof the SupremeCourt\nJANEDOE,\nIndex No.:\nPlaintiff,\n-against-\nORDERTOSHOWCAUSE\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY, INC.,\nCHI PHI CHAPTER\nHOUSEASSOCIATION,CHI PHI FRATERNITY,\nINC., CHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST,ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOFDELTADELTA\nDELTA, DELTADELTADELTASORORITY,\nZAREENENTERPRISELLC d/b/a MOONIESBAR&\nNIGHTCLUB,MATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHAN\nNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTT\nKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE\nBOARD), and ORAZIOPETITO,\nDefendants.\nUpon reading\nthe Summonsand Complaint\nin\nthis\naction,\ndated September 14, 2026,\nthe\nannexed Affirmation\nof THOMASP. GIUFFRA, ESQ., of the firm RHEINGOLDGIUFFRA\nRUFFOPLOTKIN& HELLMAN,LLP,\nattorneys\nfor\nPlaintiff,\ndated September\n14, 2026,\nthe\nannexed Affirmation\nof Plaintiff\nJANEDOEin this\nmatter,\ndated September 14, 2026, and upon\nall\nother papers and proceedings\nheretofore\nannexed herein;\nL E T THEDEFENDANTSAND/ORTHEIR ATTORNEYSAND/OROTHERLEGAL\nREPRESENTATIVES,SHOWCAUSEbefore a Justice\nof this\nCourt,\nat an IAS Part\n, Room\nof this\nCourt,\nto be held\nat the Courthouse\nlocated\nat 60 Centre\nStreet, NewYork, NYon\n\n--- Page 2 ---\nthe\nday of\n, 20___ at\nam/pm or as soon thereafter\nas counsel maybe heard, why an Order cannot be entered\ndirecting,\n1.\nThat the County Clerk enter the caption\nof the above-entitled\nmatter\nin the\ncurrent\nminute books and indices\nof actions\nand maintained\nin\nthe\noffice\nunder the title\nof:\nJANE DOE, Plaintiff,\nv.\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY,\nINC.,\nCHI PHI CHAPTERHOUSE\nASSOCIATION, CHI PHI FRATERNITY, INC.,\nCHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST, ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOF DELTA DELTA DELTA, DELTA DELTA DELTA\nSORORITY, ZAREEN ENTERPRISE LLC\nd/b/a\nMOONIESBAR & NIGHTCLUB,\nMATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHANNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTTKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE BOARD),and ORAZIOPETITO, Defendants.\nORDERED,that\npending\nthe hearing\nof this\nmotion BEFORETHEJUSTICE TO BE\nASSIGNED,the Clerk of this\nCourt,\nupon payment of the proper\nfees,\nbe and is hereby\ndirected\nto\nassign\nan index\nnumber to\nthis\nproceeding,\nand to\naccept\nfor\nfiling\na Request for\nJudicial\nIntervention\n(\"RJI\"),\nbearing\nthe following\ncaption,\nnamely:\nSUPREMECOURTOFTHESTATEOFNEWYORK\nC,OUNTYOFNEWYORK\nJANEDOE,\nPlaintiff,\n-against-\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY, INC., CHI PHI CHAPTER\nHOUSEASSOCIATION,CHI PHI FRATERNITY,\nINC.,\nCHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST,ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOFDELTADELTA\nDELTA, DELTADELTADELTASORORITY,\nZAREENENTERPRISELLC d/b/a MOONIESBAR&\nNIGHTCLUB,MATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHAN\nNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTT\nKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE\nBOARD), and ORAZIOPETITO,\nDefendants.\n2\n\n--- Page 3 ---\nand it\nis further\nORDERED,service\nof a copy of this\nOrder to Show Cause together\nwith the papers upon\nwhich\nit\nis basedpe\nserved upon the\ndefendant\non or before\nthe\nday of\n,\n20\n.\nENTER:\nJustice\nof the Supreme Court\n3","text":"--- Page 1 ---\nAt\nof the Supreme Court of\nthe State\nof NewYork County of NewYork,\nheld\nat the Courthouse located\nat 60 Centre\nStreet, NewYork, NY10007 on the\nday of\n20\n.\nP RE S E NT:\nHON.\nJustice\nof the SupremeCourt\nJANEDOE,\nIndex No.:\nPlaintiff,\n-against-\nORDERTOSHOWCAUSE\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY, INC.,\nCHI PHI CHAPTER\nHOUSEASSOCIATION,CHI PHI FRATERNITY,\nINC., CHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST,ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOFDELTADELTA\nDELTA, DELTADELTADELTASORORITY,\nZAREENENTERPRISELLC d/b/a MOONIESBAR&\nNIGHTCLUB,MATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHAN\nNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTT\nKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE\nBOARD), and ORAZIOPETITO,\nDefendants.\nUpon reading\nthe Summonsand Complaint\nin\nthis\naction,\ndated September 14, 2026,\nthe\nannexed Affirmation\nof THOMASP. GIUFFRA, ESQ., of the firm RHEINGOLDGIUFFRA\nRUFFOPLOTKIN& HELLMAN,LLP,\nattorneys\nfor\nPlaintiff,\ndated September\n14, 2026,\nthe\nannexed Affirmation\nof Plaintiff\nJANEDOEin this\nmatter,\ndated September 14, 2026, and upon\nall\nother papers and proceedings\nheretofore\nannexed herein;\nL E T THEDEFENDANTSAND/ORTHEIR ATTORNEYSAND/OROTHERLEGAL\nREPRESENTATIVES,SHOWCAUSEbefore a Justice\nof this\nCourt,\nat an IAS Part\n, Room\nof this\nCourt,\nto be held\nat the Courthouse\nlocated\nat 60 Centre\nStreet, NewYork, NYon\n\n--- Page 2 ---\nthe\nday of\n, 20___ at\nam/pm or as soon thereafter\nas counsel maybe heard, why an Order cannot be entered\ndirecting,\n1.\nThat the County Clerk enter the caption\nof the above-entitled\nmatter\nin the\ncurrent\nminute books and indices\nof actions\nand maintained\nin\nthe\noffice\nunder the title\nof:\nJANE DOE, Plaintiff,\nv.\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY,\nINC.,\nCHI PHI CHAPTERHOUSE\nASSOCIATION, CHI PHI FRATERNITY, INC.,\nCHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST, ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOF DELTA DELTA DELTA, DELTA DELTA DELTA\nSORORITY, ZAREEN ENTERPRISE LLC\nd/b/a\nMOONIESBAR & NIGHTCLUB,\nMATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHANNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTTKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE BOARD),and ORAZIOPETITO, Defendants.\nORDERED,that\npending\nthe hearing\nof this\nmotion BEFORETHEJUSTICE TO BE\nASSIGNED,the Clerk of this\nCourt,\nupon payment of the proper\nfees,\nbe and is hereby\ndirected\nto\nassign\nan index\nnumber to\nthis\nproceeding,\nand to\naccept\nfor\nfiling\na Request for\nJudicial\nIntervention\n(\"RJI\"),\nbearing\nthe following\ncaption,\nnamely:\nSUPREMECOURTOFTHESTATEOFNEWYORK\nC,OUNTYOFNEWYORK\nJANEDOE,\nPlaintiff,\n-against-\nCORNELLUNIVERSITY, INC., CHI PHI CHAPTER\nHOUSEASSOCIATION,CHI PHI FRATERNITY,\nINC.,\nCHI PHI EDUCATIONALTRUST,ALPHA\nBETAHOUSECORPORATIONOFDELTADELTA\nDELTA, DELTADELTADELTASORORITY,\nZAREENENTERPRISELLC d/b/a MOONIESBAR&\nNIGHTCLUB,MATTHEW\nINGALLS, JOHNATHAN\nNEWELL,WINSTONLEE, GILLIO LOPES, DIEGO\nSARABIA, SCOTTNORRIS, SCOTT\nKRETZSCHMAR,JOHNDOE(FACULTY), JOHN\nDOE(ALUMNI), JOHNDOES(EXECUTIVE\nBOARD), and ORAZIOPETITO,\nDefendants.\n2\n\n--- Page 3 ---\nand it\nis further\nORDERED,service\nof a copy of this\nOrder to Show Cause together\nwith the papers upon\nwhich\nit\nis basedpe\nserved upon the\ndefendant\non or before\nthe\nday of\n,\n20\n.\nENTER:\nJustice\nof the Supreme Court\n3","thumbnailUrl":"https://lucycraig.blog/media/357/thumb.webp","transcriptStatus":"not_applicable","transcriptText":"","url":"https://lucycraig.blog/media/357"}