PDF · PUBLIC LIBRARY #786
911974_26_Gillio_Lopes_v_Kathleen_M_Hochul_et_al_MEMORANDUM_OF_LAW_I_34
File: 911974_26_Gillio_Lopes_v_Kathleen_M_Hochul_et_al_MEMORANDUM_OF_LAW_I_34.pdf · 0.3 MB
SHA-256:
OCR: ready · Transcript: not_applicable
SHA-256:
e23ee8461630…8be3951b9a OCR: ready · Transcript: not_applicable
OCR / extracted text
--- Page 1 ---
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF ALBANY
In the Matter of the Application of
GILLIO LOPES,
Petitioner,
For a Judgment Pursuant to Article 78
of the Civil Practice Law and Rules
-against-
KATHLEEN (“KATHY”) M. HOCHUL, in her official
capacity as Governor of the State of New York, and
LETITIA JAMES, in her official capacity as Attorney
General of the State of New York,
Respondents.
Index No. 911974-26
Farrell, J.
MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN OPPOSITION
TO PETITIONER'S MOTION FOR LEAVE
TO AMEND
LETITIA JAMES
Attorney General of the State of New York
Attorney for Respondents Kathy Hochul,
Governor of the State of New York, and
Letitia James, New York State Attorney
General
The Capitol
Albany, New York 12224
Kaitlin Vigars
Assistant Attorney General,
of Counsel
Telephone: (518) 776-2036
Fax: (518) 915-7738 (Not for service of papers)
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
1 of 30
--- Page 2 ---
i
Table of Contents
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT .................................................................................................... 1
STATEMENT OF FACTS ............................................................................................................. 1
STANDARD OF REVIEW ............................................................................................................ 2
ARGUMENT .................................................................................................................................. 3
THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT IS PALPABLY INSUFFICIENT
AND PATENTLY DEVOID OF MERIT. ............................................................. 3
A.
The proposed amendment does not cure the defects
identified by this Court. .................................................................. 3
1.
The proposed amendment does not resolve any
nonjoinder defect. ............................................................... 3
2.
The proposed amendment does not resolve any
venue defect. ..................................................................... 10
B.
The proposed amendment raises new claims that lack merit. ....... 11
C.
The proposed amendment does not cure the procedural and
substantive defects that mandate dismissal of the Verified
Petition. ......................................................................................... 17
CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................................. 20
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
2 of 30
--- Page 3 ---
ii
Table of Authorities
Page(s)
Cases
Ahmed v. Choudhry,
___ A.D.3d ___ (1st Dep’t 2026), 2026 N.Y. Slip. Op. 06518 (Nov. 5, 2026) .........................3
Amazing Home Care Servs., LLC v. Applied Underwriters Captive Risk Assur. Co., Inc.,
191 A.D.3d 516 (1st Dep’t 2021) ..............................................................................................9
Backus v. Lyme Adirondack Timberlands II, LLC,
96 A.D.3d 1248 (3d Dep’t 2012) ...............................................................................................3
Bailey v. Vill. of Saranac Lake, Inc.,
100 A.D.3d 1089 (3d Dep’t 2012) .............................................................................................9
Capicotto v. Western N.Y. Med. Mgt., LLC,
247 A.D.3d 1492 (4th Dep’t 2026) ..........................................................................................17
Carr v. Haas,
163 A.D.3d 1212 (3d Dep’t 2018) ...........................................................................................10
Cisco v. Verizon, N.Y., Inc.,
244 A.D.3d 809 (3d Dep’t 2025) .............................................................................................10
Comm’r of the N.Y. State Dep’t of Transp. v. Polite,
236 A.D.3d 82 (2d Dep’t 2024) .................................................................................................4
Della Pietra v. State of New York,
71 N.Y.2d 792 (1988) ..............................................................................................................13
Dever v. DeVito,
84 A.D.3d 1539 (3d Dep’t 2011) ...............................................................................................3
Doe v. Roe,
___ A.D.3d ___ (3d Dep’t 2026), 2026 N.Y. Slip Op. 06502 (Nov. 5, 2026) ..........................6
Doe v. Tobin & Dempf, LLP,
247 A.D.3d 1320 (3d Dep’t 2026) .............................................................................................3
Ferguson v. Hart,
151 A.D.3d 1242 (3d Dep’t 2017) ...........................................................................................20
Gansett One, LLC v. Husch Blackwell, LLP,
168 A.D.3d 579 (3d Dep’t 2019) .............................................................................................10
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
3 of 30
--- Page 4 ---
iii
Gaul v. Cool Insuring Agency, Inc.,
250 A.D.3d 1162 (3d Dep’t 2026) ...........................................................................................12
Hennessy v. G.S. Mink Steamer & T. Claxton Hose Co. No. 2, Auxiliary Inc.,
182 A.D.3d 830 (3d Dep’t 2020) ...............................................................................................9
Jane Doe v. Cornell University, et al.,
Index No. 161704/2026 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Cnty.) ..........................................................................1
JMMJ Dev., LLC v. Woodvale Holdings, LLC,
207 A.D.3d 830 (3d Dep’t 2022) ...............................................................................................4
L-3 Communications Corp. v. SafeNet, Inc.,
45 A.D.3d 1 (1st Dep’t 2007) ....................................................................................................9
Loch Sheldrake Beach & Tennis, Inc. v. Akulich,
141 A.D.3d 809 (3d Dep’t 2016) .............................................................................................12
Matter of Bolofsky v. City of New York,
205 A.D.3d 515 (1st Dep’t 2022) ............................................................................................20
Matter of Carey (Fischer),
68 A.D.2d 220 (4th Dep’t 1978) ..............................................................................................14
Matter of Citizens Organized to Protect the Envt. v. Planning Bd. of Town of
Irondequuoit,
50 A.D.3d 1460 (4th Dep’t 2008) ..............................................................................................8
Matter of Columbia Cnty. Subpoena Duces Tecum Dated Mar. 20, 2013 (Czajka),
118 A.D.3d 1081 (3d Dep’t 2014) ...........................................................................................16
Matter of Connectivity Sys., LLC v. Zoning Bd. of Appeals of the Town of Ramapo,
227 A.D.3d 984 (2d Dep’t 2024) ...............................................................................................8
Matter of Doe v. Cuomo,
71 A.D.3d 889 (2d Dep’t 2010) ...............................................................................................16
Matter of Dondi v. Jones,
40 N.Y.2d 8 (1976) ..................................................................................................................11
Matter of Donnaruma v. Carter,
41 Misc. 3d 195 (Sup. Ct. Albany Cnty. 2013) .......................................................................16
Matter of Furnia,
232 A.D.3d 1080 (3d Dep’t 2024) .............................................................................................5
Matter of Green v. Bellini,
12 A.D.3d 1148 (4th Dep’t 2004) ..............................................................................................9
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
4 of 30
--- Page 5 ---
iv
Matter of Haggerty v. Himelein,
89 N.Y.2d 431 (1997) ........................................................................................................ 13-14
Matter of Hospital Assn. of N.Y. State v. Axelrod,
164 A.D.3d 518 (3d Dep’t 1990) ...............................................................................................8
Matter of Iglhaut v. City of New York,
247 A.D.3d 569 (1st Dep’t 2026) ..............................................................................................5
Matter of Johnson v. Pataki,
91 N.Y.2d 214 (1997) ..............................................................................................................18
Matter of McGinley v. Hynes,
51 N.Y.2d 116 (1980) ..............................................................................................................19
Matter of People v. Trump Org., Inc.,
205 A.D.3d 625 (1st Dep’t 2022) ............................................................................................20
Matter of Perkins v. Town of Dryden Planning Bd.,
172 A.D.3d 1695 (3d Dep’t 2019) ...........................................................................................20
Matter of Red Hook/Gowanus Chamber of Commerce v. New York City Bd. of Stds. &
Appeals,
5 N.Y.3d 452 (2005) ..............................................................................................................4, 8
Matter of Rice,
31 Misc.3d 838 (Sup. Ct. Nassau Cnty. 2011).........................................................................14
Matter of Schenectady Cnty. Dep’t of Social Servs. v. Noah DD.,
200 A.D.3d 1509 (3d Dep’t 2021) .........................................................................................2, 7
Matter of Schneider v. Aulisi.
307 N.Y. 376 (1954) ................................................................................................................11
Matter of Schumer,
60 N.Y.2d at 55–56 ..................................................................................................................18
Matter of Schumer v. Holtzman,
60 N.Y.2d 46 (1983) ...................................................................................................... 6, 14-15
Matter of Senior Care Servs., Inc. v. New York State Dep’t of Health,
46 A.D.3d 962 (3d Dep’t 2007) ...............................................................................................18
Matter of Shelter Is. Assn. v. Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Shelter Is.,
57 A.D.3d 907 (2d Dep’t 2008) ...............................................................................................18
Matter of Soares v. Carter,
25 N.Y.3d 1013 (2015) ............................................................................................................16
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
5 of 30
--- Page 6 ---
v
Matter of Soares v. Herrick,
20 N.Y.3d 139 (2012) ................................................................................................................6
Matter of Staten Is. Branch of the Nat’s Assn. for the Advancement of Colored People v.
State of N.Y. Grievance Comm. for the Second, Eleventh & Thirteenth Jud. Dists.,
144 A.D.3d 412 (1st Dep’t 2016) ............................................................................................16
Matter of Town of Verona v. Cuomo,
136 A.D.3d 36 (3d Dep’t 2015) ...............................................................................................18
Matter of Velez v. New York State Dep’t of Corr. & Cmty. Supervision,
163 A.D.3d 1210 (3d Dep’t 2018) .............................................................................................2
Matter of Wechsler v. New York State Adirondack Park Agency,
85 A.D.3d 1378 (3d Dep’t 2011) .............................................................................................19
Matter of Westchester Cnty. Correction Officers Benevolent Assn., Inc. v. Cnty. of
Westchester,
29 Misc. 3d 1219(A) (Sup. Ct. Westchester Cnty. 2008) ..........................................................5
Matter of Whitehurst v. Kavanagh,
218 A.D.2d 366 (3d Dep’t 1996) .............................................................................................17
Matter of Working Families Party v. Fisher,
23 N.Y.3d 539 (2014) ..............................................................................................................15
McGraw v. Shapiro,
56 A.D.2d 624 (2d Dep’t 1977) ...............................................................................................16
Milmar Food Group II, LLC v. Applied Underwriters, Inc.,
61 Misc. 3d 812 (Sup.Ct. Orange Cnty. 2018) ..........................................................................8
NYAHSA Servs., Inc., Self-Ins. Trust v. People Care Inc.,
156 A.D.3d 99 (3d Dep’t 2017) .................................................................................................2
Oglesby v. Barragan,
135 A.D.3d 1215 (3d Dep’t 2016) ...........................................................................................10
People ex rel. Wogan v. Rafferty,
208 N.Y. 451 (1913) .................................................................................................... 12, 14-15
People v. Callara,
44 N.Y.3d 623 (2025) ..............................................................................................................16
People v. Gilmour,
98 N.Y.2d 126 (2002) ..............................................................................................................12
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
6 of 30
--- Page 7 ---
vi
People v. Leahy,
72 N.Y.2d 510 (1988) ..............................................................................................................16
People v. National Rifle Assn. of Am., Inc.,
223 A.D.3d 84 (1st Dep’t 2023) ..............................................................................................20
People v. Riccio,
91 A.D.2d 693 (3d Dep’t 1982) ...............................................................................................17
People v. Romero,
91 N.Y.2d 750 (1998) ..............................................................................................................13
People v. Soddano,
86 N.Y.2d 727 (1995) ..............................................................................................................15
People v. Viviani,
36 N.Y.3d 564 (2021) ........................................................................................................ 11-13
People v. Walton,
214 A.D.2d 805 (3d Dep’t 1995) .............................................................................................19
People v. Zinkhen,
89 A.D.3d 1319 (3d Dep’t 2011) .............................................................................................19
Place v. Preferred Mut. Ins. Co.,
190 A.D.3d 1208 (3d Dep’t 2021) .............................................................................................9
Porcello v. Brackett,
85 A.D.2d 917 (4th Dep’t 1981) ................................................................................................7
Saratoga Cnty. Chamber of Commerce v. Pataki,
100 N.Y.2d 801 (2003) ..............................................................................................................4
Saxon Assoc. v. Barton,
143 Misc.2d 602 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Cnty. 1989) ............................................................................8
Singh v. T-Mobile.
232 A.D.3d 662 (2d Dep’t 2024) .............................................................................................17
Spada v. Aspen Univ., Inc.,
202 A.D.3d 494 (1st Dep’t 2022) ............................................................................................17
Stone v. Gordon,
211 A.D.3d 881 (3d Dep’t 1995) ...............................................................................................3
Swergold v. Cuomo,
70 A.D.3d 1290 (3d Dep’t 2010) .............................................................................................18
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
7 of 30
--- Page 8 ---
vii
Swezey v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith, Inc.,
19 N.Y.3d 543 (2012) ............................................................................................................4, 7
Talbot v. Johnson Newspaper Corp.,
71 N.Y.2d 827 (1988) ................................................................................................................7
Town of Southhampton v. New York State Dep’t of Envtl. Conserv.,
194 A.D.3d 1310 (3d Dep’t 2021) .............................................................................................8
Walker v. Glaxosmithkline, LLC,
161 A.D.3d 1419 (3d Dep’t 2017) .............................................................................................5
Windy Ridge Farm v. Assessor of Town of Shandaken,
11 N.Y.3d 725 (2008) ................................................................................................................6
State Statutes
County Law
§ 700.........................................................................................................................................13
§ 701(6) ........................................................................................................................ 10-11, 15
Executive Law
§ 63(2) ............................................................................................................................ 1, 13-14
Penal Law
§ 20.25........................................................................................................................................5
§ 120.20......................................................................................................................................5
§§ 220.00–220.55.......................................................................................................................5
§ 260.20(2) .................................................................................................................................5
Rules
CPLR 308.......................................................................................................................................10
CPLR 401.........................................................................................................................................2
CPLR 1001...........................................................................................................................3–4, 6–8
CPLR 1003.......................................................................................................................................3
CPLR 1024.......................................................................................................................................5
CPLR 3025(b) ..................................................................................................................................2
CPLR 3211(a)(10) .......................................................................................................................3, 7
CPLR 7802(d) ..................................................................................................................................8
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
8 of 30
--- Page 9 ---
1
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
Respondent Kathy Hochul, Governor of the State of New York (Governor) and Respondent
Letitia James, New York State Attorney General (AG, and collectively with the Governor,
Respondents), respectfully submit this memorandum of law in opposition to Petitioner’s motion
for leave to amend, dated November 5, 2026, which seeks leave to file an amended petition adding
six new parties who, like Petitioner, are defendants in Jane Doe v. Cornell University, et al., Index
No. 161704/2026 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Cnty.) (the Jane Doe Litigation). As detailed below, amendment
is not warranted because the proposed amendment is palpably insufficient and patently devoid of
merit. Accordingly, Petitioner’s motion for leave to amend should be denied, the relief requested
in the Verified Petition should be denied, and the Verified Petition and this proceeding should be
dismissed in their entirety and with prejudice.
STATEMENT OF FACTS
For a complete Statement of Facts, Respondents respectfully refer this Court to the
Statement of Facts provided in their prior filing. Dkt. No. 21 at pp. 1–3.
As relevant to this motion, Petitioner commenced this action by order to show cause on
October 7, 2026, seeking to: (1) annul Executive Order No. 64 (EO 64), which was issued by the
Governor in exercise of her superseder authority pursuant to Executive Law § 63(2), requiring the
AG to investigate the conduct of, and, if warranted, present evidence to a grand jury arising out of
the allegations in the Jane Doe Litigation; and (2) disqualify the AG from serving as special
prosecutor in the investigation and prosecution contemplated by EO 64. Dkt. Nos. 1–12.
Respondents answered, asserting objections in point of law and opposing the relief requested. Dkt.
Nos. 18–21. The Verified Petition was fully submitted on October 27, 2026. See Dkt. No. 24.
The parties then appeared before this Court for oral argument. See Dkt. Nos. 13, 27.
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
9 of 30
--- Page 10 ---
2
At oral argument, this Court raised the issue of joinder, expressing concern about its ability
to effectuate complete relief in the absence of others who may face prosecution as authorized by
EO 64.1 Dkt. No. 27 at pp. 12–13. Additionally, the Court expressed concerns about the potential
for inconsistent results amongst courts of coordinate jurisdiction. Dkt. No. 27 at pp. 12–16. The
Court also raised related questions about venue. Dkt. No. 27 at pp. 12–13, 19–20. At the
conclusion of oral argument, the Court granted Petitioner’s request to provide a further submission.
Dkt. No. 27 at p. 42. Petitioner subsequently moved by order to show cause for leave to amend
the Verified Petition to add six new parties—four new petitioners and two new respondents, who,
like Petitioner, are defendants in the Jane Doe Litigation. Dkt. Nos. 26–31. Respondents oppose.
STANDARD OF REVIEW
CPLR 401 provides applicable rules for joining new parties in special proceedings,
including proceedings pursuant to CPLR Article 78. It states that, “[a]fter a proceeding is
commenced, no party shall be joined or interpleaded . . . except by leave of court.” CPLR 401.
As relevant to any application for leave to amend made in this context, CPLR 3025(b) instructs
that leave to amend “shall be freely given upon such terms as may be just . . . .” This is a liberal
standard that permits leave “unless the proposed amendment is palpably insufficient or patently
devoid of merit.” NYAHSA Servs., Inc., Self-Ins. Trust v. People Care Inc., 156 A.D.3d 99, 102
1 As the Court noted at oral argument, Respondents did not raise any nonjoinder issue in
their answering papers. Dkt. No. 27 at p. 21. However, any such defect is only one of many other
dispositive defects requiring dismissal. See Dkt. No. 21 at pp. 5–36. Even without an objection
from Respondents, this Court may “raise the absence of a necessary party at any stage of the
proceedings upon its own motion.” Matter of Schenectady Cnty. Dep’t of Social Servs. v. Noah
DD., 200 A.D.3d 1509, 1511 (3d Dep’t 2021). Once raised, this Court may summon any necessary
party subject to this Court’s jurisdiction or, if a necessary party cannot be summoned, the court
must consider whether to proceed in the absence of that necessary party. Id.; see Matter of Velez
v. New York State Dep’t of Corr. & Cmty. Supervision, 163 A.D.3d 1210, 1211–12 (3d Dep’t
2018).
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
10 of 30
--- Page 11 ---
3
(3d Dep’t 2017); see Backus v. Lyme Adirondack Timberlands II, LLC, 96 A.D.3d 1248, 1250 (3d
Dep’t 2012); Dever v. DeVito, 84 A.D.3d 1539, 1541 (3d Dep’t 2011).
ARGUMENT
THE PROPOSED AMENDMENT IS PALPABLY INSUFFICIENT AND PATENTLY
DEVOID OF MERIT.
A.
The proposed amendment does not cure the defects identified by this Court.
Initially, Petitioner’s application for leave to amend should be denied because the proposed
amendment does not resolve the nonjoinder and venue defects identified by this Court. Dkt No.
27 at pp. 12–16; see Doe v. Tobin & Dempf, LLP, 247 A.D.3d 1320, 1323 (3d Dep’t 2026) (motion
court did not abuse its discretion in denying motion to amend complaint because proposed
amendment did not cure pleading deficiency); Stone v. Gordon, 211 A.D.3d 881, 882 (3d Dep’t
1995) (same); see also Ahmed v. Choudhry, ___ A.D.3d ___ (1st Dep’t 2026), 2026 N.Y. Slip. Op.
06518 (Nov. 5, 2026) (denying plaintiff’s request to amend its complaint because “amendment
would be futile since plaintiff cannot cure the defects”).
1.
The proposed amendment does not resolve any nonjoinder defect.
CPLR 1001 mandates that “[p]ersons who ought to be parties if complete relief is to be
accorded between the persons who are parties to the action or who might be inequitably affected
by a judgment in the action shall be made plaintiff or defendants.” CPLR 1001(a). “When a
person who should be joined . . . has not been made a party and is subject to the jurisdiction of the
court, the court shall order him summoned.” CPLR 1001(b). “If jurisdiction over him can be
obtained only by his consent or appearance, the court, when justice requires, may allow the action
to proceed without his being made a party.” Id. “Nonjoinder of a party who should be joined
under [CPLR 1001] is a ground for dismissal of an action without prejudice unless the court allows
the action to proceed without that party . . . .” CPLR 1003; see CPLR 3211(a)(10) (identifying
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
11 of 30
--- Page 12 ---
4
failure to name a necessary party as grounds for dismissal); JMMJ Dev., LLC v. Woodvale
Holdings, LLC, 207 A.D.3d 830, 831 (3d Dep’t 2022) (resolving motion to dismiss or, in the
alternative, for joinder based on absence of necessary party).
As set forth in CPLR 1001(b), the determination as to whether a court may proceed without
a necessary party requires an evaluation of five discretionary factors:
(1) whether the plaintiff has another effective remedy in case the
action is dismissed on account of the nonjoinder; (2) the prejudice
which may accrue from the nonjoinder to the defendant or to the
person not joined; (3) whether and by whom prejudice might have
been avoided or may in the future be avoided; (4) the feasibility of
a protective provision by order of the court or in the judgment; and
(5) whether an effective judgment may be rendered in the absence
of the person who is not joined.
CPLR 1001(b).
In analyzing these five factors, “[n]o single one is determinative; and while the court need
not separately set forth its reasoning as to each factor, the statute directs it to consider all five.”
Matter of Red Hook/Gowanus Chamber of Commerce v. New York City Bd. of Stds. & Appeals, 5
N.Y.3d 452, 459 (2005); see Swezey v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith, Inc., 19 N.Y.3d
543, 551 (2012). “The overall statutory design is intended to (1) guarantee that absent parties at
risk of prejudice will not be embarrassed by judgment purporting to bind their rights or interests
where they have had no opportunity to be heard and (2) protect against multiple lawsuits and
inconsistent judgments.” Comm’r of the N.Y. State Dep’t of Transp. v. Polite, 236 A.D.3d 82, 109
(2d Dep’t 2024) (quotation marks and citation omitted); see Saratoga Cnty. Chamber of Commerce
v. Pataki, 100 N.Y.2d 801, 820 (2003).
Here, in the proposed amendment, Petitioner attempts to obviate the Court’s nonjoinder
concerns by adding six new parties, who are some of Petitioner’s co-defendants in the Jane Doe
Litigation. Dkt. No. 29 at ¶¶ 12–15, 18–19; see Dkt. No. 4. However, in addition to the six parties
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
12 of 30
--- Page 13 ---
5
identified in the proposed amendment, there are multiple other defendants in the Jane Doe
Litigation that are alleged to have engaged in various misconduct that could provide a basis for
criminal liability. See Dkt. No. 4; see also Penal Law § 20.25 (proscribing when an individual
may be criminally liable for corporate conduct). Further, there are potentially innumerable
unknown others who are not named as defendants in the Jane Doe Litigation, but whose conduct
falls within the scope of the investigation authorized by EO 64 and who could be subject to future
prosecution by the AG. See, e.g., Penal Law § 120.20 (making it unlawful to engage in conduct
which creates a substantial risk of serious physical injury to another person); Penal Law §§ 220.00–
220.55 (controlled substances offenses); Penal Law § 260.20(2) (making it unlawful to sell any
alcoholic beverage to a person under twenty-one years old).2
Thus, if the necessary parties to this proceeding are the individuals whose conduct falls
within the scope of the investigation authorized by EO 64 and may eventually be prosecuted, the
proposed amendment does not obviate this Court’s nonjoinder concerns because it fails to join all
such parties. See Matter of Iglhaut v. City of New York, 247 A.D.3d 569, 569 (1st Dep’t 2026)
(motion court properly dismissed article 78 proceeding for failure to join necessary parties where
petitioner failed to identify all necessary parties “rendering it impossible to bring the parties before
the court”); see also Matter of Furnia, 232 A.D.3d 1080, 1083 (3d Dep’t 2024) (motion court’s
2 Although CPLR 1024 permits a litigant to proceed against unknown parties in certain
circumstances, this provision does not permit unknown petitioners in proceedings pursuant to
CPLR Article 78. See Matter of Westchester Cnty. Correction Officers Benevolent Assn., Inc. v.
Cnty. of Westchester, 29 Misc. 3d 1219(A) (Sup. Ct. Westchester Cnty. 2008) (“CPLR 1024, which
provides for the naming of unknown parties as defendants in an action, does not provide for the
naming of unidentified Petitioners in an Article 78 proceeding”). Regardless, Petitioner has not
named any unknown parties in the proposed amendment and otherwise has not met the
prerequisites for use of this procedural tool. Dkt No. 29; see Walker v. Glaxosmithkline, LLC, 161
A.D.3d 1419, 1420–21 (3d Dep’t 2017) (“[i]n the absence of evidence that a plaintiff made the
requisite timely and diligent efforts to identify an unknown defendant, he or she may not take
advantage of the procedural mechanism provided by CPLR 1024”).
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
13 of 30
--- Page 14 ---
6
finding that children of beneficiary of estate were necessary party to estate proceeding required
remittal to motion court to consider whether there were other unknown children that could be
identified and joined or, if they could not be joined, whether court could proceed in their absence).
At this stage of investigation, any nonjoinder of necessary parties only highlights that Petitioner’s
claim is wildly premature. Compare Matter of Soares v. Herrick, 20 N.Y.3d 139, 143, 146–47
(2012) (reaching merits of application to disqualify prosecutor after indictment was dismissed and
re-presented five times and criminal defendant commenced civil action for malicious prosecution
against prosecutor, but still denying such motion because criminal defendant failed to show any
actual prejudice), with Matter of Schumer v. Holtzman, 60 N.Y.2d 46, 56 (1983) (refusing to reach
merits of application to disqualify prosecutor at outset of investigation because “the application
for disqualification was premature”).
More pointedly, even if the six new parties identified in the proposed amendment were the
only other parties that might eventually be prosecuted, two of those parties—Matthew Ingalls
(Ingalls) and Johnathan Newell (Newell)—cannot be joined because they are beyond the
jurisdiction of the Court. CPLR 1001(b); see Windy Ridge Farm v. Assessor of Town of
Shandaken, 11 N.Y.3d 725, 727 (2008). Although the proposed amendment purports to join
Newell and Ingalls as respondents, Petitioner concedes they are not residents of this state. Dkt.
No. 29 at ¶¶ 18–19. Since neither reside in this state, Ingalls and Newell are not subject to the
jurisdiction of this Court and cannot be joined unless they consent or appear. See Doe v. Roe, ___
A.D.3d ___ (3d Dep’t 2026), 2026 N.Y. Slip Op. 06502 (Nov. 5, 2026) (court lacked general and
specific jurisdiction over defendant-undergraduate student at Cornell University because student
maintained domicile at her parents’ residence while attending college and her participation in a
university disciplinary investigation did not provide basis for exercise of long-arm jurisdiction);
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
14 of 30
--- Page 15 ---
7
Porcello v. Brackett, 85 A.D.2d 917, 917–18 (4th Dep’t 1981) (court lacked general and specific
jurisdiction over defendant-undergraduate student at Cornell University because student
maintained domicile at his parents’ residence while attending college and “social agreement
among students to share the expenses of a pleasure trip” did not provide basis for exercise of long-
arm jurisdiction); see also Talbot v. Johnson Newspaper Corp., 71 N.Y.2d 827, 829–30 (1988)
(court lacked general and specific jurisdiction over defendant-alumna of St. Lawrence University
because alumna resided in California and previous enrollment and attendance at university in New
York did not provide basis for exercise of long-arm jurisdiction). Petitioner admits that Ingalls
and Newell will not consent or appear. Dkt. No. 26 at ¶¶ 26–27. In the admitted absence of other
jurisdictional bases over these parties, they cannot be joined. See CPLR 1001(b) (a court can only
order a party to be joined if that party “is subject to the jurisdiction of the court”); Matter of
Schenectady Cnty. Dep’t of Social Servs. v. Noah DD., 200 A.D.3d 1509, 1511 (3d Dep’t 2021)
(court “plainly did not have authority to make [person] a named party to this proceeding” because
the court had no jurisdiction over person and, in the absence of jurisdiction, “the court is limited
to directing that reasonable efforts be made to join him as a party or considering whether this
matter should proceed in his absence”).
In the absence of any party this Court deems necessary, this Court must consider the CPLR
1001(b) balancing factors to determine whether it can proceed or whether it must dismiss. See
CPLR 3211(a)(10) (failure to name a necessary party as grounds for dismissal); Swezey, 19 N.Y.3d
at 554–55 (dismissing action because balance of CPLR 1001(b) factors led court to “conclude that
this case cannot be decided without the presence of the [necessary party]”). Notably, Petitioner
makes no attempt to address the CPLR 1001(b) balancing factors or otherwise request that this
Court proceed in the absence of any necessary parties. See Dkt. Nos. 26–29. Instead, Petitioner
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
15 of 30
--- Page 16 ---
8
asks this Court to effectuate joinder by giving notice to “the remaining individuals” pursuant to
CPLR 7802(d), so that these parties may intervene.3 Dkt. No. 26 at ¶ 30. This request conflicts
with Petitioner’s proposed amendment, which purports to add Ingalls and Newell as respondents,
rather than as proposed intervenors. See Dkt. No. 29 at ¶¶ 18–19. Even so, Petitioner’s request
that this Court effectuate joinder by inviting intervention is procedurally improper because
“[w]hen a necessary party can be joined only by consent or appearance, a court must engage in the
CPLR 1001(b) analysis to determine whether to allow the case to proceed without that party.”
Matter of Red Hook/Gowanus Chamber of Commerce, 5 N.Y.3d at 459.
Analyzing the requisite statutory factors here, the availability of alternative remedies cuts
strongly against proceeding in the absence of necessary parties because Petitioner—and any other
person who might eventually be indicted and prosecuted—can challenge any indictment in
numerous ways and through various procedural vehicles on a complete record that speaks to actual
and specific, rather than hypothetical and generalized, claims of prejudice. See Milmar Food
Group II, LLC v. Applied Underwriters, Inc., 61 Misc. 3d 812, 833 (Sup.Ct. Orange Cnty. 2018)
(granting motion to dismiss for failure to name a necessary party because plaintiff had an effective
remedy available in another state); Saxon Assoc. v. Barton, 143 Misc.2d 602, 603 (Sup. Ct. N.Y.
Cnty. 1989) (denying motion to amend judgment to add necessary party because plaintiff had
another effective remedy available in new plenary action or by moving for relief in separate
3 Even if joinder could be accomplished in this unorthodox manner, issuing notice to invite
intervention would unnecessarily delay this proceeding. See Matter of Connectivity Sys., LLC v.
Zoning Bd. of Appeals of the Town of Ramapo, 227 A.D.3d 984, 986 (2d Dep’t 2024); Matter of
Citizens Organized to Protect the Envt. v. Planning Bd. of Town of Irondequuoit, 50 A.D.3d 1460,
1461–62 (4th Dep’t 2008); Matter of Hospital Assn. of N.Y. State v. Axelrod, 164 A.D.3d 518, 527
(3d Dep’t 1990). Further, the claim of any intervenor similarly situated to Petitioner would fail
for all the same reasons that Petitioner’s claim fails. See Town of Southhampton v. New York State
Dep’t of Envtl. Conserv., 194 A.D.3d 1310, 1313 (3d Dep’t 2021) (motion to intervene in Article
78 proceeding properly denied where underlying claim was defective).
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
16 of 30
--- Page 17 ---
9
bankruptcy proceeding); see also L-3 Communications Corp. v. SafeNet, Inc., 45 A.D.3d 1, 11 (1st
Dep’t 2007) (“dismissal should be a last resort where plaintiff will be deprived of any remedy”
(emphasis added)).
Although the availability of alternative remedies alone is not dispositive, the remaining
factors likewise weigh against proceeding because the absence of necessary parties would only
sow confusion and chaos in this, a related proceeding, and in any potential future criminal
prosecutions that would prejudice all parties and undermine this Court’s ability to render an
effective judgment. See Matter of Green v. Bellini, 12 A.D.3d 1148, 1149 (4th Dep’t 2004)
(proceeding for writ of prohibition that sought to reinstate criminal prosecution could not continue
in the absence of party that was subject of the criminal prosecution because of “the prejudice that
might accrue to [the criminal defendant] as a result of petitioner’s failure to join him”); see also
Amazing Home Care Servs., LLC v. Applied Underwriters Captive Risk Assur. Co., Inc., 191
A.D.3d 516, 519 (1st Dep’t 2021) (dismissal of necessary party from action required dismissal of
entire action because court could not proceed in absence of necessary party where alternative
remedy was available to plaintiffs, absence of necessary party raised “[t]he possibility of multiple
conflicting judgments[,]” and no effective judgment could be rendered without necessary party).
Moreover, permitting amendment to add new parties without any excuse for nonjoinder
and at this late stage, after Respondents answered and after the parties were heard at oral argument,
would prejudice Respondents by unduly delaying this proceeding. See Place v. Preferred Mut.
Ins. Co., 190 A.D.3d 1208, 1212 (3d Dep’t 2021) (motion court did not abuse its discretion in
denying motion for leave to amend complaint where application for leave to amend was made after
joinder of issue and plaintiff offered no excuse for delay); Hennessy v. G.S. Mink Steamer & T.
Claxton Hose Co. No. 2, Auxiliary Inc., 182 A.D.3d 830, 834 (3d Dep’t 2020) (same); Bailey v.
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
17 of 30
--- Page 18 ---
10
Vill. of Saranac Lake, Inc., 100 A.D.3d 1089, 1091 (3d Dep’t 2012) (same). Although delay of a
few weeks, like the delay already incurred here, is normally not unduly prejudicial, there is a
substantial risk that this delay will be interminably prolonged by the proposed amendment because
it contemplates adding new parties to this proceeding who apparently cannot be located. See Dkt.
No. 29 at ¶¶ 18–19, 30. As a practical matter, adding new respondents whose whereabouts are
unknown would result in protracted delay while Petitioner continues his efforts to first locate and
then serve these new respondents. See CPLR 308; Oglesby v. Barragan, 135 A.D.3d 1215, 1216
(3d Dep’t 2016) (evaluating sufficiency of plaintiff’s efforts to locate out-of-state defendants for
purposes of service).
Accordingly, the proposed amendment does not, and cannot at this time, resolve the
nonjoinder issue identified by this Court such that amendment should not be permitted. See Cisco
v. Verizon, N.Y., Inc., 244 A.D.3d 809, 812 (3d Dep’t 2025) (amendment not warranted because
proposed amendment “did not cure the defects in the complaint that led to its dismissal”); Carr v.
Haas, 163 A.D.3d 1212, 1215 (3d Dep’t 2018) (amendment not warranted because proposed
amendment did not cure justiciability and pleading defects); see also Gansett One, LLC v. Husch
Blackwell, LLP, 168 A.D.3d 579, 580 (3d Dep’t 2019) (finding that granting leave to amend is
unnecessary when “amendment cannot cure the fundamental deficiencies in these claims”).
2.
The proposed amendment does not resolve any venue defect.
Although not squarely addressed in the proposed amendment, this Court, at oral argument,
also questioned whether Albany County is a proper venue for this proceeding. Dkt. No. 27 at pp.
12–13, 19–20. That question necessarily implicates a broader defect previously identified by
Respondents—i.e., that a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 is not the proper procedural
vehicle to request disqualification of the AG. Dkt. No. 21 at pp. 20–22. As detailed in
Respondents’ answering papers, County Law § 701(6) otherwise establishes requirements for
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
18 of 30
--- Page 19 ---
11
making an application to disqualify the AG that apply any time she is serving as special prosecutor
and mandate any application for disqualification be made to a superior criminal court in the county
where the criminal matter is triable. Dkt. No. 21 at pp. 20–22; see County Law § 701(6); see also
People v. Viviani, 36 N.Y.3d 564, 578–79 (2021) (disqualification processes in County Law §
serve separation of powers functions that are implicated when a court is asked to undertake “the
exceptional function of displacing an elected constitutional officer”).
The statutory requirements set forth in County Law § 701(6) serve the important comity
goals animating the Court’s questions. See County Law § 701(6). The process proscribed by
County Law § 701(6) martials the disqualification process before a single court where any criminal
matter impacted by the disqualification is triable, limiting the risk of duplicative litigation and
inconsistent results. See Matter of Dondi v. Jones, 40 N.Y.2d 8, 15 (1976) (considering principles
of comity in connection with application for a writ of prohibition to disqualify the AG from serving
as special prosecutor and finding that, because petitioner had twice moved to dismiss the
indictment on the same grounds raised in his application for writ of prohibition to disqualify the
AG, his failure to make a third application to dismiss the indictment did not bar prohibition since
a court ruling on the third application could not overrule the prior two decisions); see also Matter
of Schneider v. Aulisi. 307 N.Y. 376, 382 (1954) (proceedings in multiple counties before courts
of coordinate jurisdiction is disfavored because, even if not technically improper, as a matter of
practice this “would tend to bring the administration of justice into disrepute, and would seriously
interfere with the orderly administration of judicial work”).
B.
The proposed amendment raises new claims that lack merit.
To the extent that Petitioner’s motion for leave to amend can be read as requesting leave
to assert new factual allegations regarding the recent appointment of outside counsel to assist the
AG with the investigation authorized by EO 64, any request to so amend must be denied because
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
19 of 30
--- Page 20 ---
12
any claims directed at the appointment of outside counsel are wholly without merit. See Gaul v.
Cool Insuring Agency, Inc., 250 A.D.3d 1162, 1165 (3d Dep’t 2026) (motion for leave to amend
was “appropriately denied” because proposed amendment failed to state clam with requisite
particularity and allegations were otherwise insufficient to state a claim); Loch Sheldrake Beach
& Tennis, Inc. v. Akulich, 141 A.D.3d 809, 811 (3d Dep’t 2016) (motion for leave to amend was
improperly granted because claims in proposed amendment failed as a matter of law).
Petitioner’s new factual allegations and contentions about the appointment of outside
counsel reflect a fundamental misunderstanding of the constitutional predicate for criminal
investigations and prosecutions. See Viviani, 36 N.Y.3d at 577–579 (explaining constitutional
grant of prosecutorial authority to the AG and district attorney, how they share prosecutorial
powers, and constitutional basis for those officers to act); People v. Gilmour, 98 N.Y.2d 126, 129–
31 (2002) (explaining evolution of AG’s prosecutorial authority and basis for same as provided in
the New York State Constitutional and Executive Law § 63). Contrary to Petitioner’s contentions
that the investigation must proceed without the AG’s involvement, in fact, it cannot. See Viviani,
36 N.Y.3d at 577 (finding it unconstitutional to create a special prosecutor other than AG or district
attorney because this would “take[] an essential function from a constitutional officer and give[] it
to a different officer chosen in a different manner”); see also People ex rel. Wogan v. Rafferty, 208
N.Y. 451, 462 (1913) (finding it unconstitutional to take constitutional authority from
constitutional officer and vest that authority outside of the constitutional officer without any
involvement by the constitutional officer because it would deprive the constitutional officer of
powers vested by the constitution and “interfere with the free exercise” of the officer’s duties and
responsibilities).
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
20 of 30
--- Page 21 ---
13
The Legislature, apportioning prosecutorial authority between duly-elected constitutional
law enforcement officers, vests: (1) district attorneys with generalized prosecutorial authority in
the county where they are elected; and (2) the AG with specific state-wide prosecutorial authority
that she may exercise only when authorized by statute. See County Law § 700 (statutory delegation
of general prosecutorial authority to district attorneys); Executive Law § 63 (statutory delegation
of specific prosecutorial authority to the AG); see also People v. Romero, 91 N.Y.2d 750, 754
(1998) (“District Attorneys have plenary prosecutorial power in the counties where they are
elected” and “the Attorney-General has no such general authority . . . except when specifically
authorized by statute”); Della Pietra v. State of New York, 71 N.Y.2d 792, 796 (1988) (district
attorneys have “general prosecutorial authority for all crimes occurring in the county where
elected” and the AG has “no general prosecutorial authority . . . except when specifically permitted
by statute”). Beyond these two officers, no other person holds prosecutorial authority, nor may
such authority be delegated away to an unelected person. See Viviani, 36 N.Y.3d at 577 (finding
it unconstitutional to create a special prosecutor other than AG or district attorney because this
would “take[] an essential function from a constitutional officer and give[] it to a different officer
chosen in a different manner”); Matter of Haggerty v. Himelein, 89 N.Y.2d 431, 436 (1997) (“the
constitutional, statutory, and common-law prosecutorial authority[,]” including “the discretionary
power to determine whom, whether and how to prosecute a criminal matter” and “the responsibility
and accountability” for those actions is “not freely transferable to anyone else”).
Executive Law § 63(2) is a statutory delegation of prosecutorial authority that empowers
the AG to exercise her prosecutorial authority whenever required by the Governor. Exec. Law §
63(2). The Governor exercising her superseder authority under Executive Law § 63(2) has a single
prosecutorial alternative to the district attorney—the AG. Exec. Law § 63(2); see Viviani, 36
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
21 of 30
--- Page 22 ---
14
N.Y.3d at 579; see also Wogan, 208 N.Y. at 462 (finding it unconstitutional to take constitutional
authority from constitutional officer and vest that authority outside of the constitutional officer
without any involvement by the constitutional officer because it would deprive the constitutional
officer of powers vested by the constitution and “interfere with the free exercise” of the officer’s
duties and responsibilities). The AG acting in a superseder capacity wholly displaces the district
attorney and strips all prosecutorial authority from the district attorney. See Matter of Haggerty,
89 N.Y.2d at 436 (when the Governor requires the AG to act, the AG supersedes the local district
attorney “to assume the prosecutorial function” and “acquires all the powers and performs all the
duties in respect of such actions or proceedings before a court or Grand Jury, which the district
attorney would otherwise be authorized or required to exercise or perform.”); Matter of Carey
(Fischer), 68 A.D.2d 220, 224–25 (4th Dep’t 1978) (“[a]n Attorney-General who supersedes a
local [d]istrict [a]ttorney exercises all powers and performs all duties with respect thereto that the
local [d]istrict [a]ttorney would otherwise perform”); Matter of Rice, 31 Misc.3d 838, 842 (Sup.
Ct. Nassau Cnty. 2011) (recognizing that when Governor exercises her superseder authority under
Executive Law § 63(2), she is removing power from the district attorney).
Thus here, where the Governor has exercised her superseder authority to task the AG with
the investigation authorized by EO 64, the district attorney is divested of any prosecutorial
authority over that investigation and the only person with any prosecutorial authority to investigate
this matter is the AG. See Matter of Carey, 68 A.D.2d at 225; see also Matter of Haggerty, 89
N.Y.2d at 436 (recognizing distinction between when AG is acting under superseder authority
under Executive Law § 63(2) and fully displacing district attorney versus when AG and district
attorney are working cooperatively together). That ultimate prosecutorial authority cannot be
further divested from the AG and installed in an unelected person. See Matter of Schumer, 60
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
22 of 30
--- Page 23 ---
15
N.Y.2d at 52 (prosecutor cannot delegate away ultimate prosecutorial responsibility and authority);
see also Wogan, 36 N.Y.3d at 455–56 (constitutional authority cannot be taken away from a
constitutional officer and given to a non-elected, non-constitutional officer); see also Matter of
Working Families Party v. Fisher, 23 N.Y.3d 539, 546 (2014) (recognizing a strong “public
interest in having prosecutorial duties preformed, where possible, by the constitutional officer
chosen by the electorate”). Rather, the AG, as the sole constitutional officer currently vested with
the constitutional and statutory prosecutorial powers and responsibilities, must retain ultimate
authority and control. See People v. Soddano, 86 N.Y.2d 727, 728 (1995) (prosecutor “may allow
appearances by public officers or private attorneys so long as they are kept aware” because
prosecutors “retain the ultimate, nondelegable responsibility for prosecuting”).
Though the AG may be assisted by an unelected person, as she will be here by the outside
counsel, ultimate responsibility and accountability for the prosecution must remain with the AG
and her complete exclusion from the investigation is constitutionally impermissible. See Matter
of Schumer, 60 N.Y.2d at 52 (district attorney could not transfer fundamental responsibilities of
her office to unelected official); see also People v. Soddano, 86 N.Y.2d 727, 728 (1995)
(prosecutor “may allow appearances by public officers or private attorneys so long as they are kept
aware” because prosecutors “retain the ultimate, nondelegable responsibility for prosecuting”);
Wogan, 208 N.Y. at 462 (constitutional authority vested in constitutional officer could not be
vested outside of that constitutional officer). In certain limited circumstances, County Law §
701(6) permits further divestiture of the AG’s prosecutorial authority, but this further divestiture
can only be done on application of the AG and in a superior criminal court in the county where the
criminal matter is triable and permits transfer only to very specific alternatives. County Law §
701(6). These statutory limitations are strictly construed because “a very important purpose is
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
23 of 30
--- Page 24 ---
16
served by adhering to the plain language of the statute and to its exceptional function of displacing
an elected constitutional officer.” People v. Leahy, 72 N.Y.2d 510, 514 (1988); see People v.
Callara, 44 N.Y.3d 623, 626 (2025) (requiring strict adherence to statutory process for transferring
power from a prosecutor because of “the separation of powers concerns at play”).
Furthermore, the writ of prohibition does not lie to compel this relief because the AG’s
decision to appoint outside counsel, staffing decisions about who will work with the outside
counsel, and ultimately how the investigation is conducted through outside counsel are all
executive or administrative actions against which the writ of prohibition does not lie. See Matter
of Doe v. Cuomo, 71 A.D.3d 889, 889 (2d Dep’t 2010) (writ of prohibition did not lie against
investigation into alleged violation of immunity agreement because such action is executive in
nature); McGraw v. Shapiro, 56 A.D.2d 624 (2d Dep’t 1977) (writ of prohibition did not lie against
employment decisions because such actions are administrative in nature); see also Matter of Soares
v. Carter, 25 N.Y.3d 1013 (2015) (recognizing the “broad authority and discretion . . . to conduct
all phases of criminal prosecution” as an “executive power”). Further, Petitioner has no clear legal
right to any relief because neither he, nor this Court, may dictate how any prosecutor, including
the AG or any designee, perform their job responsibilities or exercise their prosecutorial discretion.
See Matter of Staten Is. Branch of the Nat’s Assn. for the Advancement of Colored People v. State
of N.Y. Grievance Comm. for the Second, Eleventh & Thirteenth Jud. Dists., 144 A.D.3d 412, 413
(1st Dep’t 2016); Matter of Columbia Cnty. Subpoena Duces Tecum Dated Mar. 20, 2013
(Czajka), 118 A.D.3d 1081, 1083 (3d Dep’t 2014); Matter of Donnaruma v. Carter, 41 Misc. 3d
195, 210–11 (Sup. Ct. Albany Cnty. 2013).
Likewise, a writ of prohibition should not issue as a matter of discretion given the
availability of other adequate remedies available to Petitioner if he is eventually indicted and
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
24 of 30
--- Page 25 ---
17
prosecuted. See Matter of Whitehurst v. Kavanagh, 218 A.D.2d 366, 368–69 (3d Dep’t 1996)
(affirming denial of writ of prohibition seeking to prohibit district attorney from proceeding with
prosecution of indictment because petitioner could raise his claims “by moving against the
indictment” and “the ordeal of a criminal trial with the possibility of conviction, standing along is
not sufficiently harmful to warrant the use of prohibition even if the harm sought to be redressed
implicates a constitutional right”); see also People v. Riccio, 91 A.D.2d 693, 694 (3d Dep’t 1982)
(direct appeal from criminal conviction considering criminal defendant’s claim that prosecution
by AG acting pursuant to Executive Order made in exercise of Governor’s superseder authority
was improper or beyond scope of AG’s authority).
Accordingly, Petitioner’s request for leave to amend to add new factual allegations
regarding the appointment of outside counsel should be denied because these new factual
allegations are wholly without merit. See Capicotto v. Western N.Y. Med. Mgt., LLC, 247 A.D.3d
1492, 1494 (4th Dep’t 2026) (motion court properly denied motion for leave to amend because
proposed amendment was patently devoid of merit “where it fails to cure any of the defects that
warranted dismissal”); Singh v. T-Mobile. 232 A.D.3d 662, 667 (2d Dep’t 2024) (motion court
properly denied motion for leave to amend because proposed amendment “was palpably
insufficient and patently devoid of merit, as it failed to cure any of the defects that warranted
dismissal”); Spada v. Aspen Univ., Inc., 202 A.D.3d 494, 495 (1st Dep’t 2022) (motion court
properly denied motion for leave to amend because proposed amendment “would not cure the
deficiency” in the original pleading).
C.
The proposed amendment does not cure the procedural and substantive
defects that mandate dismissal of the Verified Petition.
Finally, leave to amend must also be denied because the proposed amendment does not
cure the numerous other procedural and substantive defects that require dismissal of the Verified
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
25 of 30
--- Page 26 ---
18
Petition and preclude this Court from granting relief. See Matter of Town of Verona v. Cuomo,
136 A.D.3d 36, 45 (3d Dep’t 2015) (motion court did not abuse its discretion in denying cross-
motion to amend because proposed amendment was “plainly lacking in merit” where petitioners
lacked standing and court lacked jurisdiction over dispute); Swergold v. Cuomo, 70 A.D.3d 1290,
1294 (3d Dep’t 2010) (motion court did not abuse its discretion in denying motion for leave to
amend because proposed amendment “suffer[ed] from the same jurisdictional deficiencies” and
“also would have been dismissed in its entirety”); Matter of Senior Care Servs., Inc. v. New York
State Dep’t of Health, 46 A.D.3d 962, 964 (3d Dep’t 2007) (affirming motion court determination
that denied motion for leave to amend because claims in proposed amendment were substantively
meritless).
As detailed in Respondents’ answering papers, Petitioner’s claim fails three important
justiciability criteria—ripeness, standing, and presentation of a political question. Dkt. No. 21 at
pp. 5–20. These threshold considerations are dispositive and not cured by the proposed
amendment. See Matter of Shelter Is. Assn. v. Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town of Shelter Is., 57
A.D.3d 907, 908–10 (2d Dep’t 2008) (finding “Supreme Court did not err in denying . . .
petitioner’s cross motion which was for leave to amend the petition . . . as none of the petitioners,
including the four additional petitioners that the original petitioners sought to add had standing”);
see also Matter of Johnson v. Pataki, 91 N.Y.2d 214, 223 (1997) (judicial review of the Governor’s
exercise of her superseder authority “is generally limited to determining whether the State
Constitution or the Legislature has empowered the Governor to act and does not include the
manner in which the Governor chooses to discharge that authority”); Matter of Schumer, 60
N.Y.2d at 55–56 (request to disqualify prosecutor raised separation of powers concerns and “was
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
26 of 30
--- Page 27 ---
19
premature and not justiciable” because it was made before information about how prosecution
might play out was known).
Similarly, as also discussed in Respondents’ answering papers, Petitioner’s claim is
procedurally improper because the writ of prohibition does not lie against executive action or in
the absence of a clear legal right to relief. Dkt. No. 21 at pp. 22–28. Neither defect is remedied
by the proposed amendment as the claim in the proposed amendment is identical to the claim
alleged in the original petition, both of which impermissibly seek a writ of prohibition against
executive action and do not identify any clear entitlement to relief. See Matter of Wechsler v. New
York State Adirondack Park Agency, 85 A.D.3d 1378, 1379 (3d Dep’t 2011); see also Matter of
McGinley v. Hynes, 51 N.Y.2d 116, 123–25 (1980) (writ of prohibition did not lie against
investigative activities of special prosecutor because investigation “had not yet progressed to a
stage where individual wrongdoers had been identified or discrete charges of criminality raised”).
These procedural defects notwithstanding, and as also discussed in Respondents’
answering papers, issuance of the writ of prohibition is also not warranted as a matter of this
Court’s discretion. Dkt. No. 21 at pp. 28–31. Further, Petitioner fails to establish any actual
prejudice that would require disqualification of the AG. Dkt. No. 21 at pp. 31–35. Nothing in the
proposed amendment addresses these defects. See People v. Zinkhen, 89 A.D.3d 1319, 1320 (3d
Dep’t 2011) (criminal court did not err in denying motion to dismiss indictment that alleged the
prosecutor should be disqualified because did not provide proof of any actual prejudice and only
asserted “an inference of impropriety, which is not enough on its own to require [the c]ourt to
dismiss the indictment or disqualify the District Attorney’s office”); People v. Walton, 214 A.D.2d
805, 808–09 (3d Dep’t 1995) (denying CPL 440 motion “[a]lleging that statements made by the
prosecutor to the press constituted prosecutorial misconduct and that he was the victim of selective
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
27 of 30
--- Page 28 ---
20
prosecution” because defendant failed to show that he was prejudiced or that this resulted in
selective application of the law and defendant otherwise had ability to protect his rights through
other means at trial and in pre-trial motions); see also People v. National Rifle Assn. of Am., Inc.,
223 A.D.3d 84, 90–91 (1st Dep’t 2023) (AG’s public statements that “displayed animus” towards
defendant organization did not amount to selective prosecution); Matter of People v. Trump Org.,
Inc., 205 A.D.3d 625, 626–27 (1st Dep’t 2022) (AG’s public statements about subject of subpoenas
did not did not amount to selective prosecution).
Accordingly, the proposed amendment is devoid of merit such that Petitioner’s motion for
leave to amend must be denied. See Matter of Bolofsky v. City of New York, 205 A.D.3d 515, 515-
16 (1st Dep’t 2022) (finding “Supreme Court providently exercised its discretion to deny leave to
amend to add additional parties after respondents challenged the standing of petitioner” because
“petitioners cannot show that they will actually be harmed by the challenged administrative action
as the harm is entirely conjectural”); Matter of Perkins v. Town of Dryden Planning Bd., 172
A.D.3d 1695, 1697–98 (3d Dep’t 2019) (finding “no abuse of discretion by Supreme Court in
denying the motion for leave to amend the petition” because the proposed amendment “is devoid
of merit”); Ferguson v. Hart, 151 A.D.3d 1242, 1243–45 (3d Dep’t 2017) (reversing motion court
determination that granted motion for leave to amend because proposed amendment was “palpably
insufficient on its face” since claims were inconsistent with applicable law).
CONCLUSION
Respondents respectfully request that Petitioner’s motion for leave to amend be denied in
its entirety and with prejudice.
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
28 of 30
--- Page 29 ---
21
Dated: Albany, New York
November 16, 2026
LETITIA JAMES
Attorney General of the State of New York
Attorney for Respondents Kathy Hochul,
Governor of the State of New York, and
Letitia James, New York State Attorney
General
The Capitol
Albany, New York 12224
By: _/s/ Kaitlin Vigars___________
Kaitlin Vigars
Assistant Attorney General, of Counsel
Telephone: (518) 776-2036
Fax: (518) 915-7738 (Not for service of papers)
TO:
All counsel of record (via NYSCEF)
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
29 of 30
--- Page 30 ---
Printed [Reproduced] on Recycled Paper
22
STATEMENT PURSUANT TO 22 NYCRR 202.8-b
I, Kaitlin Vigars, affirm under penalty of perjury pursuant to CPLR 2106 that the total
number of words in the foregoing Memorandum of Law, inclusive of point headings and footnotes
and exclusive of pages containing the caption, table of contents, table of authorities, and signature
block, is 6,776 words. The foregoing Memorandum of Law complies with the word count limit set
forth in 22 NYCRR 202.8-b. In determining the number of words in the foregoing Memorandum
of Law, I relied upon the word count of the word-processing system used to prepare the document.
/s/ Kaitlin Vigars
Kaitlin Vigars
FILED: ALBANY COUNTY CLERK 11/16/2026 05:45 PM
INDEX NO. 911974-26
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 34
RECEIVED NYSCEF: 11/16/2026
30 of 30
PUBLIC DISCUSSION
Comments & replies
No account is required. Comment anonymously, or sign in with a pseudonymous account if you want to manage your comments later. Comments are user speech, not editorial findings.
No comments yet. You can be the first without creating an account.